21 - 23 janvier 2019
Disrupting Global Health Narratives: Alternative Perspectives of the World Bank and its Influence on Global Health Development
- Winters Janelle, University of Edinburgh, PhD Fellow
- Tichenor Marlee, University of Edinburgh, Postdoctoral Research Fellow
The project is a three-day workshop to bring together social scientists and global health policy analysts to discuss the role of the World Bank in global health over the last 40 years. The fundamental goal of the workshop is to provide alternative global health histories to a monolithic one that traces influence, policy, and investment from the Global North to the Global South.
Global Health Governance Programme at the University of Edinburgh
Disrupting Global Health Narratives: Alternative Perspectives on the World Bank’s Influence on Global Health
Day 1 – Monday, Jan 21
9:00 Scene Setting: Introducing the ‘standard World Bank narrative’ and the work of the Economic Gaze team
Speaker: Devi Sridhar (University of Edinburgh, UK)
9:15 Goals of the workshop: What do we currently know about the Bank’s global health influence and impact? What themes need revision or closer scrutiny? What methodologies and sources could help us reframe the Bank’s work?
Speakers: Marlee Tichenor and Janelle Winters (University of Edinburgh, UK)
9:30 Panel 1 – Governing Global Health: What influence has that Bank had on global health in relation to other international organizations?
Chair: Janelle Winters (University of Edinburgh, UK)
9:40 – Martin Gorsky (London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, UK)
9:50 – Sophie Harman (Queen Mary University of London, UK)
10:00 – Jo Vearey (Wits University, South Africa)
10:10 – Yusra Shawar (Johns Hopkins University, USA)
10:30 Coffee break
12:00 Working lunch
Discussion questions: How do we delineate ‘health’ at a development institution like the Bank? IHME definitions, water/sanitation, social services, percentages, etc.?
13:00 Panel 2 – The Economic Lens: How has the Bank and its affiliates justified its investment in health? How has its conception of health impacted other global health actors, especially in the private sector?
Chair: Felix Stein (University of Edinburgh, UK)
13:10 – Mark Hellowell (University of Edinburgh, UK)
13:20 – Anuj Kapilashrami (Queen Mary University of London, UK)
13:30 – James Akazili (Navrongo Health Research Center, Ghana)
13:40 – Alexis Walker (Johns Hopkins University, USA)
13:50 Coffee break
19:00 Talk from Francisco Songane (Founding Director of the Partnership for Maternal, Newborn and Child Health, Switzerland; Former Minister of Health, Mozambique) (19:00-19:20) over dinner
Day 2 – Tuesday, Jan 22
9:00 Panel 3 – The Knowledge Bank and the Role of Metrics: What ideologies have underpinned the development of health metrics at the Bank, and how influential have these metrics been outside of the Bank? How is the Bank’s evidence produced and used?
Chair: Marlee Tichenor (University of Edinburgh, UK)
9:10 – Jean-Paul Gaudillière (Cermes3, France)
9:20 – Katherine Kenny (University of New South Wales, Australia)
9:30 – Tianxin Pan (Melbourne University, Australia)
9:40 – Katerini Storeng (University of Oslo, Norway)
11:00 Coffee break
11:30 Panel 4 – Power and Decision-Making: Are countries really the Bank’s clients? How has the Bank engaged country partners, and how have country partners held the Bank to account?
Chair: Genevie Fernandes (University of Edinburgh, UK)
11:10 – Jesse Bump (Harvard University, USA)
11:20 – Purnima Menon (International Food Policy Research Institute, India)
11:30 – Sumegha Asthana (Jawaharlal Nehru University, India)
11:40 – Suerie Moon (Graduate Institute-Geneva, Switzerland)
13:15 Working lunch
Discussion question: What alternative narratives have we seen? What themes have we seen?
14:30 Wide group discussion about themes:
What narratives and alternative ways of looking at the Bank’s history and influence have we seen? Have we seen alternate timelines and changing chronologies? What alternate themes?
15:15 Coffee break
15:45 Small group discussion about methodologies:
What frameworks have we used or could we use to study the Bank? What do they offer, and what are their drawbacks, especially in terms of the complex web of actors and power dynamics?
Day 3 - Wednesday, Jan 23
9:00 Wide group discussion: Review of methodologies outlined yesterday and what sources could be used
What types of sources could be used for more inclusive research, and in what contexts (in-country sources like newspaper and social media; activist and critic voices; financial data; local archives; donor country materials, etc.)?
Output: Outline for a workshop summary article, focusing on themes, methodologies, and sources
10:30 Coffee break
11:00 Targeted group work for outputs:
Break-out groups, based either on the four panel themes or other themes that have emerged, led by the Global Health Governance Group team